Yes, we were, and I don't see the relavence of Holt's numbers.We were discussing Smith's size. In reality, his size isn't a concern. He will add a good 10-15 over his playing career. He hasn't been the first receiver to lack build, and won't be the last one. Not picking him because of his size is almost like overlooking all the other great things he does better than some of the prospects named alongside him during this draft.
You refuse to admit that guys of that size/build typically do not turn out to be great.
The ones that do are few, and far between, and were generally also in very specific situations.
Holt and Harrison were both great players. They are also the exception, not the rule.
Using them as examples is, therefore, a bad comparison, IMO.
Let's put it another way.
Would you prefer Tory Holt, or Julio Jones.
Marvin Harrison, or Megatron?
I get that you want the Dolphins to have a dynamic, take over a game type reciever. So do I, but let's not grasp at straws with the #3 pick.