not a fan of Carr but if he were to come in, there won't be a competition. He is the Day 1 starter. Upgrade from the standpoint of you being able to run a real NFL offense but i would hold for something better
What if our next coach pushes for us to acquire Derek Carr
- Thread starter juniorseau55
- Start date
It's funny how good other team's qbs always look, but our qbs could never survive throwing an interception to end the game.
Are we really at the point that we are just making up alternate timeline scenarios about which we start threads?
SMH
claytonduper
Starter
- Joined
- May 23, 2004
- Messages
- 2,428
- Reaction score
- 3,250
In my opinion, Carr has a few more years of experience which makes him better than Tua currently. Carr would not survive the surroundings we had on offense this past year. Only Murray or Mahomes can consistently make plays without much protection. Then the questions is who do these guys throw to? Eventually these running QB's will probably get hurt. Everyone else, including Brady, would struggle mightily with the talent and coaching we had this past year. That is why we must give Tua the weapons and protection he needs (Again not top 5 but just average).
You guys should really think about a Tua vs (insert player) sub forum...
Both Gase and Flores with Grier as the GM had final say on the 53. With the communication coming out that they want a collaborative coach, I don't see why the next one wont have control over the 53 as well.
fin007
Club Member
Clickbait question and I took the bait. Your question poses a situation that is absurd. Short answer: Raiders will not part with Carr and Carr doesn't want to play for any team other than the Raiders. Go read Carr's statements on the issue of where he wants to play.
I have a great idea brother.
Let's partner up on an app that ppl can do exactly that. We could make a fortune.
We can call it "playing with yourself", or "Masturbation".......
It’s all about other performances not just the interception. I don’t mind when Tua throws an interception but with an inconsistent game like he recently had the?‘s go to the forefront because he doesn’t have a lot of history of success.
I like Dak Prescott, some of my cowboy fan friends do not like him. I think his complete body of work is above average as a whole so therefore I would cut him some slack. Even as rookies, Josh Allen ,Herbert and Burrow, I see what they can do more often than not, and it’s unreal, Sure, the occasional poor decision interception will occur, and that’s OK but I look at the complete body of work and not just a bad decision here or there.
Tua has to play better and we’ll find out next year. He deserves a real OC.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2007
- Messages
- 1,977
- Reaction score
- 3,500
No, of course he wouldn't. And who says the Raiders want to get rid of him?
TrogdorTheBurninator
Club Member
Logic doesn't belong here sir.
Carr has been in the league for a while and only has two playoff berths.
The sensible thing for everyone is to give Tua 1 full year with a decent OL and RB/WR room and see what happens. Then next year new coach will have 2 1st round picks to potentially get a new QB if they don't feel he was a good fit.
lynx
Club Member
Why Carr? Is he absolutely better than Tua? I don't think anyone could say that.
You got to think the next coach will be onboard with Tua in 2022 or the Dolphins will go in a different direction
You got to think the next coach will be onboard with Tua in 2022 or the Dolphins will go in a different direction