I only see the Bengals doing this trade if they
You argument just doesn’t make sense. While Burrow may not have had same type stats in 2018, he was still a good QB for LSU that season.
Baker and Murray only had one outstanding season as QB’s in college and they both went #1 in the draft.
Tua has shown to be injury prone and while he might have been the top pick in the draft if he was healthy, I would take your One year wonder over Tua at this point in their careers.
I have no problem at all with the trade scenario of the Dolphins giving up the draft picks to the Bengals to move up and draft Burrow. I think Burrow is going to have a better NFL career than Tua simply because I don’t think Tua will even be in the league in 5 years because of how injury prone he is.