A perfect example of the chasm between Wilson and Tannehill...No, the difference is the Seattle football team runs the football very effectively unlike us, AND plays great defense (but who really cares about the other 52 and coaching right?).
Can't wait till RW chokes in epic fashion in the playoffs AGAIN, and all his defenders still prop him up as a HoFer because he won a SB with a team so unbelievable my mother could have been their QB lmao.
Not sure if it’s been mentioned already because I haven’t read the entire thread yet but this is ridiculous. If you take the games against the Dolphins defense as a measuring stick for QBs you will be severely disappointed. Geno Smith would be in the Hall of Fame if he had played the Dolphins every week.
The Bills scored 29.5 points per game against our defense but on the season they scored 17 points per game. Which is 3 points per game less than our anemic offense. So hold your praise for Josh Allen just a bit.
None of our crap QBs ever had the chance of 7 years, 2 different HCs, several different OCs, dozens of different WRs, OL players etc.
The Dolphins partnered the guy with more players and coaches in a 7-year span than a top hooker has Johns in that same time span.
If you continuously exchange variables and leave one constant and the results remain continuously ****ty you might want to look at the only constant in that equation.
You won't get a third for a shell of a QB who the NFL knows is going to get the boot sooner or later and probably won't take a paycut.Damn, it’s like a bunch of bitter exgirlfriends in this thread.
Tyrod ****ing Taylor was had for a third. That’s the minimum you ask for in return, but I’d ask for a second since Tannehill has been much better than Taylor. You guys need to get this Mike Tennenbaum bullshit out of your head and stop giving away resources because your little feelings are hurt he didn’t win a super bowl.
I disagree unless your bar for success is extraordinarily low. It's not some conspiracy or league-wide mistake that Gase is getting multiple HC interviews and Tannehill is maybe worth a mid-round pick. Anything better than a 5th would leave me ecstatic. I just don't see Tannehill taking a team to the playoffs. I can see Gase achieving that type of success.
I agree with your sentiment that I appreciate Tannehill's toughness and he put up with our franchises incompetence the same way we put up with his perennial average play for 7 years.
When it comes to Foles however...it's very easy for me to make a case that Foles is flat out a better QB than Tannehill. More touchdowns per-game, better YPA, better career rating...you could tell me it was just based on his one great regular season but if THill had that kind of season in his resume we wouldn't hear the end of it. I could also point to his clutch performances (Playoffs and Super-Freakin-Bowl) compared to Tannehill's anti-clutch performances in "win or go home" games (ducks against awful divisional opponents).
No one should be trashing Tannehill but there is no need to prop up his play. We've got a full-blown sample size.
Tannehill cap number makes him damn near untradeable. Any team wanting would only do so if he wanted to redo his deal.
Just release the guy, hes shell-shocked ala David Carr.
Which QB would you take? Which QB is better?LOL
You guys have lost all objectivity on the matter.
Rich Kotite was a HOT item after being fired by the Eagles
Which QB would you take? Which QB is better?
QB A
23-21-1 record as starter (.523 winning %)
53-20 TD pass / Int = 2.65 TD pass - 1 Int ratio
79 TD (Pass + Rush) - 25 Turnovers (Int + Fumbles lost =5) = 3.16 TD - 1 Turnover ratio
2 winning seasons out 3 as starter (started 50% of teams games or more)
1 playoff appearance
QB B
42-46 record as starter (.477 winning %)
123-75 TD pass / Int = 1.64 TD pass - 1 Int ratio
129 TD (Pass + Rush) - 96 Turnovers (Int + Fumbles Lost = 21) = 1.34 TD - 1 Turnover ratio
1 winning season out of 6 as starter
0 playoff appearances
Which QB would you take? Which QB is better?
QB A
23-21-1 record as starter (.523 winning %)
53-20 TD pass / Int = 2.65 TD pass - 1 Int ratio
79 TD (Pass + Rush) - 25 Turnovers (Int + Fumbles lost =5) = 3.16 TD - 1 Turnover ratio
2 winning seasons out 3 as starter (started 50% of teams games or more)
1 playoff appearance
QB B
42-46 record as starter (.477 winning %)
123-75 TD pass / Int = 1.64 TD pass - 1 Int ratio
129 TD (Pass + Rush) - 96 Turnovers (Int + Fumbles Lost = 21) = 1.34 TD - 1 Turnover ratio
1 winning season out of 6 as starter
0 playoff appearances
No, they surrounded him with a GREAT defense and running game, the team is not successful when those things are not in place like last year.
And I would wait until he at least beats the Cowboys to call him a great QB, if he puts up another stinker then his playoff play will be s*** outside of Super Team 2013, not that anyone will care but that will be the truth.