Do you agree with re-signing Hartline?

[defiant]

...with successful QBs, or maybe like 12-13 teams.

Which was covered in the "successful teams" part

If youre not that interested in being successful, by all means, order up another year of Tannehill/Hartline. Maybe they can explode for 3 TDs this year! Meanwhile Tom Brady throws 3 TDs to Welker in a single game.

 

[NCFINFAN13]

If it's what the market dictates then it is what it is. Next.

 

[Dolphinokie]

I think 6 is ok. I believe its not worth a 11 to 14 mil risk to pick up Wallace or Jennings... We can draft a wr n a te in the draft

 

[defiant]

Yeah, why would we want the fastest player on the field who gets open all the time and scores touchdowns? Let's re-sign the guy who makes no plays at a playmaking position, draft a couple fat people, a RB, and call it a life.

 

[ohall]

I want him for 3 years 13.5 Million or 4 years 17 Million. That is plenty of money for a #2 WR.

The question I keep asking myself, is that what a AVG #2 WR is worth in today's NFL?

I guess when the FA period is over this year we'll a better answer.

---------- Post added at 09:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:24 PM ----------

Yeah, why would we want the fastest player on the field who gets open all the time and scores touchdowns? Let's re-sign the guy who makes no plays at a playmaking position, draft a couple fat people, a RB, and call it a life.

So you think the signing of Hartline will stop us from going after Wallace or Jennings?

 

[defiant]

The question I keep asking myself, is that what a AVG #2 WR is worth in today's NFL?

I guess when the FA period is over this year we'll a better answer.

---------- Post added at 09:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:24 PM ----------



So you think the signing of Hartline will stop us from going after Wallace or Jennings?

No, just remarking that wanting to sign Hartline and pass on Wallace is ABSOLUTELY RETARDED

 

[marinobestever]

he is NOT worth any more than 3 mil per season tops...what a waste of money if hes worth 6 million what the hell is wallace worth 10 million? You can get any amendola type receiver to replace hartline in a flash...IRELAND HAS TO GO ARE YOU READING THIS JEFF???????????????

 

[kvado16]

he is NOT worth any more than 3 mil per season tops...what a waste of money if hes worth 6 million what the hell is wallace worth 10 million? You can get any amendola type receiver to replace hartline in a flash...IRELAND HAS TO GO ARE YOU READING THIS JEFF???????????????

Probably not, you're clearly as impulsive and uninformed as most of the fans on here.

 

[JAMAICA]

Wouldn't give him more than $4-5 million per season. He's nothing even close to elite. I don't even consider him much of a quality #2; I think he only survives as a #2 WR if your #1 is a premier superstar WR. He's more of a #3 to me. Dude has serious issues finding the endzone. His stats are inflated, IMO, I mean, someone's got to get the ball when there isn't much talent out wide.

Wouldn't start on half the teams in the league.

 

[jason_taylor]

Really surprised to see people clicking the $5-$7 million range.

i sure didnt , i picked 4-5 mil range , But if we could have gotten Jennings for around 8 mil , which i think will be his numbers after teams look at him and say that there not going to give that much for a injured prone player ,and Jennings stock will drop, then we will look like the dummies when and if that happens , yeah for 3 mil more Jennings would have been my selection .

 

[MrEd]

Although I voted that I don't want Hartline back "at all" (because I feel he is easily replaced and isn't strong), I still understand the logic of bringing him back as a security blanket to play off of a deepthreat. But it's obvious he's coming back so it is what it is. Now it does seem to be hinting to a Davone Bess departure sooner rather than later...especially if we find Tavon Austin staring us in the face at pick 42 and he's still on the board.

 

[Dr. Phin]

At 6M per....we can chalk this up as Mistake #1 for this year by Ireland..

 

[jason_taylor]

Yeah, why would we want the fastest player on the field who gets open all the time and scores touchdowns? Let's re-sign the guy who makes no plays at a playmaking position, draft a couple fat people, a RB, and call it a life.

you know what the sad part is ? half the people would agree with you,, really.

 

[MexDolfan]

At 6M per....we can chalk this up as Mistake #1 for this year by Ireland..

Please illustrate us about potential actions to save such mistake....

... signing Hartline for $4 Millions/season?
I think it's the market that states $6 Millions/season is a fair price for a 1000+ yards receiver

... signing both Wallace & Jennings each asking for $12+/year?
That's too much money for WR spots, eating all cap needed to add quality veterans for CB, RB & TE.

... waiting until draft to pick a couple of starting WR?
I could see guys like Cordarrelle Patterson or Keenan Allen starting with fine results on 2013, but other names like Ryan Swope or Justin Hunter will require a slower maturation process.

In my mind signing Brian Hartline for 6 Millions/season is well used money. But that should not avoid Dolphins from adding Mike Wallace on free agency and Ryan Swope during draft.

 

[MD]

Please illustrate us about potential actions to save such mistake....

... signing Hartline for $4 Millions/season?
I think it's the market that states $6 Millions/season is a fair price for a 1000+ yards receiver

... signing both Wallace & Jennings each asking for $12+/year?
That's too much money for WR spots, eating all cap needed to add quality veterans for CB, RB & TE.

... waiting until draft to pick a couple of starting WR?
I could see guys like Cordarrelle Patterson or Keenan Allen starting with fine results on 2013, but other names like Ryan Swope or Justin Hunter will require a slower maturation process.

In my mind signing Brian Hartline for 6 Millions/season is well used money. But that should not avoid Dolphins from adding Mike Wallace on free agency and Ryan Swope during draft.

Is 6 mil per a fair price for a guy who has scored 3 TDs in 3 years?