Dr. Phin
Scout Team
- Joined
- Aug 30, 2008
- Messages
- 8,346
- Reaction score
- 66
YEAH Wilson fumbled 10 times and Tannehill 9.
Oh, wait, I just destroyed your point.....sorry.
Who is wearing the ring right now? So, your point was?
YEAH Wilson fumbled 10 times and Tannehill 9.
Oh, wait, I just destroyed your point.....sorry.
t
Take bradford off and put cam newton
Who is wearing the ring right now? So, your point was?
So, to be a bottom 20 QB, there only has to be 12 better than him. You could probably name 12 better than him yourself...
If you want to bitch about Omar, at least do it when he is off-base. He isn't in this case. We hope Tannehill gets better, but right now he is a bottom 20 QB.
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Wilson
Rothlesburger
Flacco
Luck
Manning
Smith
Rivers
Romo
Manning
Foles
Palmer
Cutler
Stafford
Ryan
Bradford
The subject at hand isn't who would you want to be your quarterback for the next 5-10 years, so your qualifier isn't germane to the conversation.Two things, post the full quote. I said "I will add however two of those four have shown reasons to not chose them if you were building a team today, being Manning and Brady look to be in decline." and it makes perfect sense in that statement.
Yet he still managed to have a better season than RT, throw for 4300+ yard, have a 25-11 TD/Int ratio, and get his team to the AFC Championship Game despite a rash of player injuries that probably would have been near impossible to overcome for many other teams. If you look at Brady's stats from 2001-2007, you'll see many years where he had very similar numbers to last year.Second point is Brady looked like garbage half the season...
That's nonsense. You have no way of knowing how he'd do with an entirely different set of personnel. You have no way of knowing if Brady would have the same trouble getting on the same page with Wallace that RT had. You have no way of knowing how far the level of play of our wide receivers would have risen because Brady was tossing them the rock....and the Dolphins would of been like 2-6 with him the first half of the season.
LOL ...yeah, his weak arm only threw for 5400+ yards and set the season TD record. I wish RT had an arm that weak.Manning looked stellar but ultimately was exposed for a lack of arm strength.
I'd want Brady or Manning around for a few years so that the qb I had in the wings could learn as much from them as possible. If we're going to talk about what's best in the long run, that's it.I never implied Tannehill was better at this time or will ever be better but I would take (sure it's a gamble) the Tannehill future to Brady and Manning if all were placed on this roster.
So, to be a bottom 20 QB, there only has to be 12 better than him. You could probably name 12 better than him yourself...
If you want to bitch about Omar, at least do it when he is off-base. He isn't in this case. We hope Tannehill gets better, but right now he is a bottom 20 QB.
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Wilson
Rothlesburger
Flacco
Luck
Manning
Smith
Rivers
Romo
Manning
Foles
Palmer
Cutler
Stafford
Ryan
Bradford